In 2023, the comparison between Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo shows a nuanced picture, with Ronaldo leading in raw goal-scoring numbers but Messi excelling in playmaking and overall impact.
Goals and Assists
- Ronaldo scored significantly more goals in 2023, with about 50 goals compared to Messi's 28 in the calendar year
- Ronaldo also had slightly more assists (15 vs. 12) in 2023
- Ronaldo played more matches and minutes overall, which partly explains his higher goal tally
Efficiency and Play Style
- Ronaldo had a better goals-per-game ratio (0.92 vs. 0.64) and minutes per goal (96 vs. 131.7) in 2023, indicating higher scoring efficiency
- Messi, however, contributed more in terms of playmaking, with higher numbers in decisive passes and dribbling success, showcasing his role as a creative force on the field
- Messi also had more assists per minute played, highlighting his dual threat as scorer and creator
Achievements and Impact
- Messi won significant individual honors in 2023, including his 8th Ballon d’Or and Times Magazine's Athlete of the Year, and helped his teams win titles like the French League and Leagues Cup
- Ronaldo won the Saudi Pro League Cup in 2023 and continued to score prolifically in the Saudi league, but his team achievements were fewer compared to Messi's
- Messi is often regarded as having a greater overall impact on his teams’ performances and is praised for his artistry and playmaking ability, while Ronaldo is noted for his physical prowess and goal-scoring consistency
Career Context
- Over their careers, Ronaldo has scored more total goals (907 vs. 849), but Messi has a better goals-per-game ratio (0.79 vs. 0.73)
- Messi has more assists and is considered a superior dribbler and playmaker, while Ronaldo excels in headers and scoring with his weaker foot
- Messi has won more league titles and individual awards, while Ronaldo has the edge in Champions League goals and appearances
- Messi led Argentina to a World Cup victory in 2022, a major milestone that Ronaldo has not matched
Summary
- In 2023 specifically, Ronaldo was more prolific in goal-scoring and had more appearances, while Messi was more influential in playmaking and won more prestigious individual awards and team trophies.
- Overall, many experts and fans consider Messi the better player due to his creativity, impact on team play, and individual honors, while Ronaldo is celebrated for his athleticism, goal-scoring record, and longevity
Thus, the "better" player in 2023 depends on the criteria: Ronaldo was the superior goal-scorer that year, but Messi had a greater overall impact and collected more accolades. Many regard Messi as the more complete and influential footballer, especially in terms of artistry and team contribution.
